Pacific
Symphony
| Ravel: |
|
Le Tombeau de Couperin |
| Rodrigo: |
|
Fantasia para un gentilhombre |
| Beethoven: |
|
Symphony No. 5 in C-minor |
Giancarlo Guerrero, conductor
Sharon Isbin, guitar
Friday, December 11, 2009 at Renée and Henry
Segerstrom Concert Hall, Costa Mesa, Calif.
he concert billed as “Beethoven’s Fifth” by the Pacific
Symphony last Friday drew a near-capacity crowd to the
OC’s Segerstrom Concert Hall. To their pleasant surprise,
they were also treated to delicate Spanish guitar music
alongside Beethoven’s monumental revolutionary work.
|
In a way, both Ravel’s Le Tombeau de Couperin and Rodrigo’s
Fantasia para un gentilhombre are as retro-leaning as the
Beethoven’s Fifth was forward-looking. It was a nice, often
startling, contrast that added much drama to the evening’s
proceedings. To boot, the Pacific Symphony players were on top
form, the strings sounding full and lush against the mellifluous
woodwinds and brilliant percussions. The tonal balance among
different orchestral sections was smooth and faultless from the
loudest fortissimo to the softest pianissimo. This is one
beautiful-sounding orchestra.
Despite its somber title and dedication to the war dead, Ravel’s
Le Tombeau de Couperin was written as an homage to a gentle
bygone era of the French Baroque masters (Rameau, Lully) and should
be played in a lively and non-sentimental manner. Conductor
Giancarlo Guerrero did exactly that and captured Ravel’s
colorful orchestration brilliantly. The Forlane and
Rigaudon dances exploded with vitality; the Menuet ebbed
and flowed gracefully, featuring Jessica Pearlman’s lovely oboe
playing.
American guitarist Sharon Isbin has a loyal following of fans
and, judging from her performance of Rodrigo’s Fantasia para un
gentilhombre, it’s not hard to see why. There was great finesse
and crystalline clarity in her playing, perhaps just a tad slow and
over-reticent in the first movement (Villano & Ricercare) for my
taste, but elsewhere the playing was spirited and spontaneous.
Isbin played the soaring melodies of the “Españoleta” with deep
feeling and high poetry. Her faultless scales and arpeggio work
allowed her to dance with the orchestra in the "Danza de las hachas"
and even challenge it winningly in the final festive dance
“Canario”. The orchestra also contributed magnificently to the
partnership. The loud bird-calls in the “Canario” might be a bit
too much, but the unbounded enthusiasm was infectious.
After the intermission, we heard a thrilling account of
Beethoven’s Symphony No. 5 in C-minor that showcased the Pacific
Symphony as a world-class ensemble. Conductor Guerrero responded to
the powerful ‘fate’ theme with tremendous force, but also opened up
to the warm lyricism of the secondary subject that follows (again
featuring Ms. Pearlman’s memorable solo oboe). The slow movement,
Andante con moto, was lyrical yet vibrant with a forward
motion. Curiously, the Scherzo was played without a repeat of the
trio, but the Allegro finale was uncut with all the repeats. In any
case, it was a powerful reading but with many memorable subtleties
and great lyrical warmth. The Pacific Symphony strings were
firmly-balanced from the highest strings to the lowest bass, with
stellar contributions from the winds and brasses.
The concert was a double triumph for Beethoven as well as the
Pacific Symphony.
To
purchase tickets for the Pacific Symphony's 2009/10 season, call
(714)755-5799 or visit online
www.pacificsymphony.org
Truman C. Wang is editor-in-chief of Classical Voice,
whose articles have appeared in the San Gabriel Valley Tribune, the
Pasadena Star-News, other Southern California publications, as well
as the Hawaiian Chinese Daily.
|