Classical Voice  : Notable Notes
 


Notable Notes --  October, 2008

     Lang Lang recital   
    
Mozart Requiem in San Pedro
     LA Phil - Firebird (Complete), Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto
     Los Angeles Opera - Madama Butterfly
     LA Master Chorale - Rachmaninov & Haydn
     Olivier Latry, organ recital
     Musica Angelica - Concerto!
 





October 1
  Lang Lang recital launches OC arts season
 

PROGRAM: Franz Schubert- Piano Sonata in A Major No.20, D.959. Bela Bartok- Piano Sonata, BB.88.  Claude Debussy- Preludes Book 1: "Les collines d'Anacapri", "La fille aux cheveux de lin", "La cathedrale engloutie", "Minstrels", Book 2: "Bruyeres", "Feux d'artifice", "La terrasse des audiences du clair de lune".  Frederic Chopin- Polonaise Op. 53 in A-flat Major "Heroic".  Encores- Chopin Etude No. 3 Op.10, Rimsky-Korsakov "Flight of the Bumblebee". 
 

F

or the grand opening of its 2008-2009 concert season, the Philharmonic Society of Orange County outdid itself with flashy media glitz and free-flowing champagne that made everyone who attended feel like royalty.  As you approached the gleaming glass-and-metal facade of the Elizabeth & Henry Segerstrom Concert Hall, you were greeted with colorful lights emitting from a fanciful light sculpture in the lobby by Brite Ideas with lighted tiles arranged in a vertical spiral.  And as you entered the lobby, you could see the sheer delight and amazement on people’s faces. 

The colorful light show was a nice precursor to the equally colorful piano playing that was to follow.

26-year-old Chinese superstar piano virtuoso Lang Lang wowed the capacity crowd with the exciting and exhilarating athleticism of his playing.  His reputation had preceded him at the 2008 Beijing Olympics, and last night he sounded as if he was aiming for gold in the piano speed competition.  Certainly, the Bartok Piano Sonata (BB. 88) was hammered away at a breakneck speed, the fifteen-minute first Allegro finished in an unheard-of ten minutes (yes I timed it).  The idiomatic folk-like episodes in the final Allegro might have gotten shortchanged, but at least the piece ended with a loud bang for the buck.  The audience clearly was ecstatic.

The same thing could be said about Lang Lang’s Chopin Polonaise Op. 53 in A-flat Major (“Heroic”) – full of stunning octaves, double octaves and glistening arpeggios played as fast as possible, but not much in the way of belle époque grace (á la Rubinstein) or volatile lyricism (á la Horowitz).  

Lang Lang’s response to the desolate and romantic sound world of  Schubert’s A-Major Piano Sonata (No. 20, D.959) was intensely personal but ultimately unconvincing.  Lang Lang painted a dark, grotesque picture of the A-Major Sonata’s soundscape, building up the first-movement Allegro impressively with superb dynamic shading of the first subject as it progressed from its innocent glitter in the opening bars to its triumphant re-entry in the recapitulation.  His treatment of the lyrical second subject, however, was rhythmically too deliberate and disjointed to be enjoyable.  Often the music halted in mid-phrase for a rest where is none in the score.  This highly personalized, somewhat narcissistic, playing also plagued the simple song-like Andantino, one of Schubert’s finest creations, in which the cataclysmic storm erupting in mid-section served almost as a relief from the unrelenting lack of lyricism.  Lang Lang played the Scherzo as a strange, macabre dance as if from a Mahler Symphony.  The final Rondo-Allegro fared better with a more direct, warmer approach, but it was too little, too late.

Claude Debussy’s Preludes found Lang Lang much more in his elements.  Debussy’s acerbic wit and sparkling impressionistic colors suited Lang Lang like a glove.  The grotesqueness, sounding foreign in Schubert’s Scherzo, proved positively delightful in the “Minstrels”.  The Spanish hillside came alive with fetching Iberian rhythms in “Les collines d’Anacapri”.  The mythical sunken Cathedral raised up in full splendor of chants and bells in “La cathedrale engloutie”.  In all seven selections, Lang Lang played with great charm and sparkle, unleashing the kaleidoscopic colors of Debussy’s sound world.  As befitting a showman, the order of the selections in the printed program was re-arranged to start softly with “La fille aux cheveux de lin” (“The girl with the flexen hair”) and end with the crowd-pleasing showpiece “Feux d’artifice” (“Fireworks”).

For encores, we heard Chopin’s Prelude – delivered with more elegance than the “Heroic” Polonaise – and the lighter-than-air Flight of the Bumblebee from Rimsky-Korsakov’s opera The Tale of the Tsar Saltan. 

As opening nights go, the program and artist involved on this occasion were typically celebratory rather than substantive.  Nonetheless, whatever misgivings one might have about Lang Lang’s hyper-kinetic playing, there is no denying that he is a fine pianist on the way to great things, and the Philharmonic Society should be congratulated for a splendidly festive opening night.  For those looking for more substance, I suggest not to miss Cecilia Bartoli’s recital on February 17, 2009.

- Reviewed by Truman C. Wang

Related link:  Lang Lang Soiree
 

                                                                                                                    


 





 

October 2   Mozart Requiem in San Pedro

PROGRAM: W.A. Mozart- Requiem, KV.626
                      Dr. Sheridan J. Ball, conductor
                      Golden State Pops Orchestra
                      Southern California Master Chorale
                      Warner Grand Theater, San Pedro, California
 

S

an Pedro is a hardworking blue-collar town better known for its busy seaport and high crime rates than for its arts.  Valiant efforts have been waged in recent years to make the downtown safer and more inviting to visitors and businesses, but there is still much work to be done.  Last night’s performance of Mozart’s Requiem at the historic Warner Grand Theater sounded a positive note for the city and inspired hope for its future.

Dr. Sheridan J. Ball conducted the Golden State Pops Orchestra and the Southern California Master Chorale in a gripping, powerful reading of Mozart’s unfinished masterpiece.  Despite the uneven quality of the musicians and singers involved (the botched opening of Benedictus had to be restarted), Dr. Ball was able to coax some fine things out of them.  The Chorale singing achieved a nice balance between male and female voices, sounding intensely dramatic in the fugal Kyrie, fearsome in Confutatis, and appropriately poignant in Lacrimosa.  The final Communion was powerfully exhilarating.  Dr. Ball’s overall view of the Requiem was not that of fear, but of comfort and hope.  It was interesting to note that the timpani played with less force in the Dies irae (wrath of the Judgment Day) than in the Communion (the affirmation of God’s compassionate nature). 

The solo numbers were all taken by various singers from the Chorale with variable results.  They were not helped by the dry acoustics of the Warner Grand, either.  Nonetheless, there were a few standouts – bass Harold Clousing in Tuba Mirum, tenor James Callon in Recordare and the silver-voiced soprano Grace Lee in Benedictus and Agnus Dei.  

Kudos for Dr. Ball and the City of San Pedro for bringing art and beauty, against all odds, to a much-maligned community.   For a list of upcoming attractions at the Warner Grand, visit www.grandvision.org

- Reviewed by Truman C. Wang
 

Related link: Golden State Pops Orchestra
 




 





 

October 11 
LA Phil - Firebird (Complete) & Tchaikovsky
PROGRAM: Stravinsky- Fireworks.  Tchaikovsky- Piano Concerto No. 1 in B-flat Minor, Op. 23.  Stravinsky- The Firebird (complete ballet 1910).  Esa-Pekka Salonen conducts Los Angeles Philharmonic.  Yefim Bronfman, piano

I

n the time-honored ‘saving the best to the last’, maestro Esa-Pekka Salonen opened his final season with L.A. Phil with fireworks -- Stravinsky’s Fireworks, that is.  This “brainy little showpiece”, as Richard Taruskin famously called it, lasts a mere five minutes but showcased the L.A. Phil musicians (chiefly the flutes, violins and horns) in a colorful and exuberant display of virtuosity.

The orchestra’s newfound brilliance was due in part to new hires in the brass and percussion sections, who proudly made their presence known in no uncertain terms.

The opening night program featured the Firebird Suite (1919), fifteen minutes of selected dances and ‘Best of’ from the Symphonic ballet.  Last night, the original 1910 Ballets Russes version of the Firebird, all forty-five minutes of it, was heard in all its symphonic (and stereophonic) splendor thanks to Salonen’s thrilling and gutsy interpretation, based on a keen awareness of the revolutionary nature of this 20th-Century masterpiece.  In the brooding chromatic opening measures, the strings played softly and ominously (the ghost of Dukas’ sorcerer was clearly audible).  In “Sunrise”, the off-stage brasses cut through the auditorium like a bright beam of sun ray.  The “Infernal Dance” and “Capture of Ivan Tsarevitch” erupted in a savage orgiastic frenzy of clashing brasses and percussions, foreshadowing Stravinsky’s next two ballets Petrouchka (1911) and Rite of Spring (1913). The purely lyrical numbers – Princesses’ Round Dance, Lullaby, Firebird’s entreaties – featured some ravishing solo turns by Ariana Ghez’s oboe (round dance) and William Lane’s French horn (finale).

The official program notes of the Los Angeles Philharmonic contain two glaring factual errors, long dismissed by historians.  The first – Stravinsky started to write Fireworks in 1908 as a wedding present but did not complete it until a year after the wedding in 1910.  In any case, it was Scherzo fantastique, not Fireworks (though both premiered in the same concert in 1910), that had put Stravinsky in line to receive the Firebird commission from Ballets Russes Director Serge Diaghilev.  Secondly, the oft-repeated tale of Liadov being the original intended composer for Firebird and Stravinsky as the second-in-line is also incorrect.  It was actually Nikolai Tcherepnin, Diaghilev’s staff conductor, after whose withdrawal the commission was passed down to Liadov, Glazunov, Sokolov and eventually to the young Stravinsky.   

October has proved to be a good month for pianists in L.A.: Lang Lang, András Schiff,  Piotr Anderszewski,  Jean-Yves Thibaudet, and Yefim Bronfman – a veritable hit parade of talents bringing their own distinctive styles to the classic masterworks.  Bronfman’s broadly romantic style was perfect for Tchaikovsky’s B-flat Minor Piano Concerto No. 1.  He had no problem carving out the broad melody in the opening fanfare (never to be heard again after its first appearance) or the long-arcing span of the Andantino folksong.  Most impressive was his avoidance of emotional overindulgence and over-pedaling, playing the Allegro climaxes and folk dance with great force and clarity without turning the notes into a haze of sounds.  It was a classy performance matched by Salonen’s fiery but controlled conducting.  The L.A. Phil strings had seldom sounded better than in the Andantino accompaniment, lightly-bowed and radiantly beautiful.
 

- Reviewed by Truman C. Wang




 




 
October 19  Olivier Latry plays organ at Segerstrom Hall
PROGRAM: J.S. Bach- Prelude and fugure in G-Major, BWV 541. Cesar Franck- Chorale No. 2 in B-minor from Trois chorals, M.39.  Widor- Andante sostenuto from Symphonie gothique, op. 70.  Marcel Dupre- Prelude and fugure in G-minor, Op 7. No.3 (1912).  Charles Tournemire (transcribed by Maurice Durufle)- Choral-Improvisation sur le "Victimae paschali" from Cinq Improvisations for organ.  Messiaen- L'apparition du Christ ressuscite a' Marie Madeleine from "Livre du Saint Sacrement".  Thierry Escaich- Evocation No. 2.  Olivier Latry- Improvisation on submitted themes.
 

T

he business of pipe organ building is fraught with hidden dangers.  Ostensibly, there is the construction of the physical instrument, with its myriad of stainless steel pipes of various lengths and diameters; then, there is the hall itself, the aural space that allows the organ to breath and come to life – or not.  It is an unknown X-factor that will not become apparent until the organ is played for the first time.  Fortunately, the Renée and Henry Segerstrom Concert Hall is equipped with movable walls and ceiling panels that should take care of any acoustical crisis, should the need ever arise.

After the new organ’s vigorous marathon workout by French virtuoso organist Olivier Latry last Sunday afternoon, one could safely say that the organ fits the hall like a glove, as it were.  It is not only an beautiful instrument to behold, but sounds great as well.  

Nevermind the music was mostly obscure Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century organ works by such names as Widor, Dupre, Tournemire, Messiaen and Escaich.  The collective effect of brilliant sounds and spectacular playing achieves a spiritual intensity that is the purpose of these works.  The diverse organ effects started with Bach’s lushly romantic G-Major Prelude and fugue, BWV 541, and continued with Franck’s large-scale B-minor Chorale No. 2 that explores the extremes in the organ’s registers and dynamics, and concluded with a dazzling improvisation of “America” from West Side Story, played in the fugal style of J.S. Bach – a fine tribute to the host country as well as to Latry’s own prodigious skills.

Other works on the program played with the organ’s specialized sound effects, these including spatial separation of echoes in Widor’s Andante sostenuto (which miraculously floated on angel’s wings), gradual buildup of echoes in Tournemire’s Choral Variations, and gradual fading of echoes in Messiaen’s Resurrection of Jesus Escaich’s Evocation No. 2 features a stabbing ostinato bass that Latry played with both his feet, and upper melodies playable only by adroit contortion of his upper torso and limbs.  Olivier Latry may be an organist of great depth at the Cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris; he is vastly entertaining as well. 

If there was one aspect of the concert that did not quite hit the sweet spot, it was the somewhat bass-shy acoustics of the Hall, which rendered the rumbling tremolo in the Messiaen less than Earth-shaking.  But I am sure that can be resolved by tweaking those acoustic panels.

All in all, a memorable Sunday afternoon of organ spectacular at the Segerstrom Concert Hall.
 

- Reviewed by Truman C. Wang




 



 




 
October 12  LA Master Chorale - Rach + Haydn
PROGRAM: Sergei Rachmaninov - Selections from "Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom".  Franz Joseph Haydn - Harmonie Mass.  Los Angeles Master Chorale, Grant Gershon, Music Director.
 

T

he long summer wait is over. How wonderful to sit down in still amazing Walt Disney Concert Hall, to recognize friends and familiar faces from seasons past, to note new subscribers, new faces in the Chorale, and … and new, stylish concert wear by the women of the Master Chorale, created by LA’s own Karolyn Klisel – black on black, each dress studded with Swarovski crystals to reflect and illuminate the warm Hall lighting, and featuring a very modest V-neckline that embarrasses no one and somehow manages to fit all ages, shapes and sizes. The women looked and moved elegantly!

Maestro Grant Gershon took the stage, and with minimal greetings whistled a single note, gave the downbeat, and oh, the glorious a cappella chord that burst from 96 throats in perfect harmony was truly awesome, initiating the first of 11 movements chosen from the Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom, Opus 31, written in 1910 by Sergei Rachmaninoff to begin the ensemble’s 45th Season. Trained in proper Orthodox Church Russian by Chorale member Alexander Ruggieri, the Chorale fed every emotion, from contemplative to ecstatic, from reflective to anguished and on to exultative, providing the listener with as near-religious an experience as a believer would have in church. Soprano Sun Joo Yeo contributed in the movement translated “We Hymn Thee”.

After intermission, the Master Chorale was joined by the excellent Chorale Orchestra organized by Steve Scharf for Joseph Haydn’s ultimate major work, the Harmoniemesse, a work of significant length and content the title of which, Maestro Gershon explained to the early arrivals, refers not to “harmony” in the English-language sense, but to the German expression for “wind section” i.e., oboes, clarinets, bassoons, horns, and one flute, that play a significant role in the course of the composition, particularly in the Agnus Dei. Tempi were well within the generically acceptable, except for the Benedictus, which Maestro Gershon took at a speed to rival anyone, anywhere, the effect of which tended to trivialize the text (Blessed is he who cometh in the name of the Lord).

The solo quartet of Deborah Mayhan, soprano, Adrianna Manfredi, alto (who sometimes found the tessitura a bit too low for comfort), Daniel Chaney, tenor and Gregory Geiger, bass, who was substituting for the indisposed Reid Bruton, all drawn from the ranks of the Master Chorale, were extraordinarily well chosen for the task, and sang like a true quartet instead of the usual four soloists all taking their turns.  But when their brief solo turns came, they were more than equal to the challenge, most notably Ms. Mayhan, whose soprano soared into the Haydnesque heights without edge or struggle. Tenor Kevin St. Clair and alto Tracy Van Fleet joined the quartet to form a thrilling sextet in the finale, a brilliant compositional coupe that served the purpose brilliantly.

This inaugural concert, filled as it was with so much music of comfortable and familiar harmonies, will be followed next month by a concert of the mirror opposite. All aboard!
 

- Reviewed by Douglas Neslund



 




 
October 25  Musica Angelica - Concerto! 

PROGRAM:  J. B. Bach: Orchestral Suite No. 4 D Major Vivaldi: Concerto C-major for Sopranino recorder and Strings Graun: Double Concerto for Gamba and Violin, c minor Telemann: Double Concerto for Gamba and Recorder, a minor J. S. Bach: Brandenburg Concerto No. 4, G Major.
Martin Haselboeck, conductor. Vittorio Ghielmi, gamba. Marion Verbruggen, recorder; Ilia Korol, violin 
 

M

usica Angelica, So Cal’s premier Baroque music ensemble, opened its 2008-2009 season at the Colburn School's Zipper Hall with a nice collection of rarely-heard concertos and the welcome return of Dutch recorder virtuoso Marion Verbruggen

Making their debuts were Baroque violinist Ilia Korol and viola da gamba player Vittorio  Ghielmi, who performed with expected virtuosity but also a surprising shade of dark poignancy in Graun’s C-minor Double Concerto for Violin and Gamba.  It was as if the raspy chatter of the Baroque violin was being tempered by a melancholy gamba.  Ghielmi and Korol played with and off of each other in one unbroken harmonious fabric of the music.

In the tradition of the Baroque concerto, the soloists played along with the orchestra during the concerted tutti passages  (Baroque operas and Handel’s oratorios, too, have the soloists join the coro.) 

Verbruggen shone and sparkled on her squeaky-high sopranino recorder (almost like the modern piccolo in timber) in Vivaldi’s C-major Concerto for Recorder and Strings.  Of the 500-plus concertos that Vivaldi wrote, about 20 are for the recorder.  The C-major concerto is a prime example, showing a fine contrast of textures and sonorities between the recorder and the string orchestra.   She later shared the spotlight with Ghielmi in Telemann’s A-minor Double Concerto for Gamba and [Alto] Recorder.  The slightly melancholy timber of her alto recorder blended nicely with the viola da gamba. 

On the program were two Bach’s – J.S. and his distant older cousin J.B. (Johann Bernhard).  Artistically, J.B.’s Orchestra Suite No. 4 in D-major may be a distant contender for a Baroque masterpiece, but it was a cheerful, delightful antipasto to open the concert.  In J.S.’s Brandenburg Concerto No. 4 in G-major, Verbruggen was joined by Rotem Gilbert on the alto recorder in a spirited performance.   This is a concerto where the use of modern flutes would have inevitably destroyed the delicate sonorities of the orchestration, particularly in the echo effects of the slow movement.  The players of Musica Angelica all operated on high octane under the superb leadership of maestro Martin Haselboeck, and provided unfailing support for the team of soloists. 

 
- Reviewed by Truman C. Wang
 



 

Douglas Neslund is Classical Voice correspondent and a noted voice/choral teacher in Los Angeles. 

Truman C. Wang is editor-in-chief of Classical Voice, whose articles have appeared in the San Gabriel Valley Tribune, the Pasadena Star-News, other Southern California publications, as well as the Hawaiian Chinese Daily.

 

 

[ previous | back to top ]