Classical Voice  : Notable Notes
 

Notable Notes --  October/November, 2004

By
Truman C. Wang
November 30, 2004


Oct 27  Ivo Pogorelich, piano
PROGRAM: Beethoven- Sonata No. 24 in F#, Sonata No. 32 in c; Rachmaninov- Moments musicaux Op.16. No.1; Scriabin- Sonata No. 2; Liszt- Etudes d'execution transcendente No. 5, 8, 10.
It was at UC Irvine's Barclay Theatre that Pogorelich chose to make his long-awaited appearance -- in a difficult, almost willful, program of late Beethoven and Liszt that many sane pianists would have balked at. Many would no doubt question Pogorelich's sanity in the perverse disfigurement of the Beethoven sonatas -- an appalling vision of Beethoven as seen through an opium-induced haze.  It was almost as surreal as the total lunar eclipse outside the theatre.  The exhilarating accounts of the Liszt and Scriabin (and Balakirev's Islamy encore) nonwithstanding, the harm had already been done.  It was the memory of the grotesquely disfigured Beethoven that stuck.  A most bizarre recital.
 
  Oct 29  Carmen, Los Angeles Opera
CAST: Catherine Malfitano (Carmen), Mario Malagnini (Don Jose), Angela Marambio (Micaela), Erwin Schrott (Escamillo), Nicola Luisotti conducts
In the Third Act of "Carmen", bullfighter Escamillo and Don Jose are fighting a duel when Carmen enters to break up their fight.  With Jose prostrate on the ground, Escamillo exclaims, "Ahh Carmen! how grateful am I to see you come to save my life!"   It was this kind of numbskull stage direction (by Emilio Sagi) and heavy-handed conducting by Luisotti that nearly tanked the show.  It was only saved by the devilish charms of hotthrob baritone Erwin Schrott (last seen here as Figaro and Don Giovanni), who excelled vocally as well as, dare I say, physically. Malfitano's Carmen was neither lithe nor youthful, but compensated in the dramatic delivery in Act Four.  Marambio's Micaela easily overpowered the wimpy-sounding Don Jose of tenor Malagnini.  There was clearly no contest between Carmen's two suitors.  Schrott was the hands-down winner. 
The sets and costumes from Madrid's Teatro Real were bright and cheerful, especially in the Lilla Pastia's ultra-posh tavern in Act Two. 
 
  Nov 13  Howard Shelley, piano.  Pasadena Symphony
PROGRAM: Dvorak- Scherzo capriccioso, Stravinsky- The Firebird Suite (1919), Rachmaninov- Piano Concerto No. 3 in d minor
I was alarmed at first to see a world-class pianist sight-read through a beloved repertory warhorse -- an astounding feat without the aid of a page turner.  I am jesting, of course.  This was veteran British pianist Howard Shelley's second appearance with the Pasadena Symphony in as many years, and, despite fears of memory lapse, his fingers had not failed him -- for they turned out a steller, adrenaline-rushing performance that would have put many pianists half his age to shame (yes I am referring to the likes of Lang Lang and Volodos.)  The Pasadena players were top-notch under conductor Jorge Mester. This is an orchestra that, on its worst night, still manages to sound beautiful.  The Dvorak and Stravinsky works were well executed for their solo turns (chiefly Leanne Becknell's oboe), but there was no mistaking what the audience went to hear.  They got their money's worth in the deafening applause and shouts of bravo for the Third Concerto.  Kudos again for Mr. Shelley and the Pasadena Symphony.
 
  Nov 27  Vanessa, Los Angeles Opera
CAST: Kiri te Kanawa (Vanessa), Lucy Schaufer (Erika), Rosalind Elias (Baroness), John Matz (Anatol), David Evitts (Doctor), Simone Young - conductor
The last time I heard Kiri live was 10 years ago in San Francisco Opera's "Capriccio".  At the time, I thought I was hearing the most beautifully exquisite sound imaginable coming from a human throat.  The intervening years have been kind to Kiri who, at 60, sounds and looks half her age.  Moreover, her fabled silvery voice has acquired a deeper resonance that had heretofore proved elusive.  The role of Vanessa, with its Isolde-like dramatic soliloquies and lyrical outbursts, would have defeated the young Kiri, but is now a perfect vehicle for her.  It is truly the crowning achievement of Kiri's career.  The rest of the cast were uniformly strong, too, with Lucy Schaufer's unforgettable Erika and Rosalind Elias' chilling portrayal of the Baroness.  A great find was tenor John Matz, a bouncer-turned-opera singer, who sounded a lot like the young Pavarotti but unfortunately swallowed all his vowels, rendering most of his words unintelligible.  Conductor Simone Young whipped up some real passions in the pit with lush romantic strings (think Barber's "Adagio for Strings").  The sets -- a spiral staircase, sparsely furnished great room, and a hall of mirrors -- are minimalist but highly effective in depicting the opera's desolate emotional landscape.  This is quite the finest thing I've seen at L.A. Opera all year long.


 

   

Truman C. Wang is editor-in-chief of Classical Voice, whose articles have appeared in the San Gabriel Valley Tribune, the Pasadena Star-News and other Southern California publications.

 

 

[ previous | back to top ]