Classical Voice  : Notable Notes
 

Notable Notes --  September/October, 2007

By Truman C. Wang


  Sep 27  Pacific Symphony, Marc-André Hamelin, piano
PROGRAM: R.Strauss- Don Juan, Op.20, Mozart- Piano Concerto No. 17 in G. K453, Ravel- Piano Concerto for the Left Hand, Suite No. 2 from Daphnis & Chloe. Carl St. Clair, conductor

T

his week on PBS, a new seven-part documentary, simply titled “The War”, chronicles the trials and tribulations of war-torn American families during the Second World War.  It is a labor of love for its producer Ken Burns, who sought to understand how the different ethnic and socioeconomic strata of the American society coped with the war and coexisted with one another.  The entire series is nicely tied together by Wynton Marsalis’ inspired musical score.

In many ways, Maurice Ravel’s musical contributions to the First World War – La Valse and the Piano Concerto for the Left Hand being the best known – were meant to tie the different peoples and countries together in one common language of love and optimism.  Ravel, the composer, and Wittgenstein, the pianist, fought on different sides during the war but came together after the war.  It was a classic case of art triumphant over evil.  The triumphant spirit was hugely evident in the performance by pianist Marc-André Hamelin, who made an imperious entry in the opening bars of the concerto.  The orchestra was superb in its precision and brio under the skillful baton of Carl St. Clair.  The dreamy, jazz-flavored episode was sensitively handled.  The Left-Hand Concerto and the Daphnis et Chloé Suite No. 2 both showcased the brilliant virtuosity of the Pacific Symphony players, particularly Benjamin Lulich’s superfine clarinet playing.  The sheer colors and brilliance unleashed by the orchestra were truly astounding. 

The bold, swaggering Don Juan of Richard Strauss was faithfully painted by the orchestra in big, brash strokes of tonal colors.  What I missed, however, was the highly passionate and sensuous playing in the love scene that’s found on my old recording of Fritz Reiner and the Chicago Symphony from the 1950’s. 

Mozart’s Piano Concerto No. 17 in G Major (K.453) got off to an iffy start with the soloist hitting some wrong notes and indulging in over-articulated phrasing.  The superb acoustics of the Segerstrom Concert Hall did not help his case.  Things improved somewhat in the Andante (a precursor to Barbarina’s minor-mode aria in Le Nozze di Figaro), where Mr. Hamelin’s deliberate tempo and a well-judged pause from maestro St. Clair added much to the poignancy of the music.  The rondo finale was exciting and cheerful as it should be. 

In the end, it was the happy collaboration of the orchestra and the soloist that transcended all criticism.  Just as Ken Burns’ “The War” showed America at its finest hour, last Thursday night’s concert showed the Pacific Symphony fully in its elements, auspiciously heralding a season of great concerts to come. 

For information on the Pacific Symphony's 2007-2008 season, visit www.pacificsymphony.org  


    October 2  Kiri Te Kanawa, soprano  
PROGRAM: Mozart-Cantata "Die ihr des unermesslichen Weltalls"K.619, Strauss- "Staenchen", "Die Nacht", "All mein Gedanken", "Morgen", "Zueignung", Duparc- "La vie anterieure", Chanson triste, Phidyle, Poulenc-Voyage a' Paris, Hotel, Les chemins de l'amour, Heggie- Monologue from Masterclass, Britten- Evening, Copland- Why do they shut me out of Heaven? Wolf-Ferrari- Rispetto, Puccini- Morirer? Sole e amore (Mattinata)

T

he Philharmonic Society of Orange County has a long and illustrious history of presenting serious classical music in an area of Southern California that is better known for its high surf than for its high art. The Vienna Philharmonic, the Berlin Philharmonic, pianist Murray Perahia, the Vienna Boys Choir, conductors Daniel Barenboim and Claudio Abbado, and now, soprano Kiri Te Kanawa, have all passed through and left their indelible marks. The erstwhile land of citrus crops has grown and matured into a major arts center in the U.S.

At 63, the age at which many singers are still carrying on with diminished resources, Kiri has wisely decided to make her exit – with as much grace and dignity as Mozart's Countess she so famously portrayed on stage – on a Farewell tour that took her to Southern California last Tuesday night.

Fifteen years ago, I first saw Kiri Te Kanawa in San Francisco Opera’s Capriccio and promptly declared it “in terms of sheer beauty and loveliness of sound, the most perfect lyric soprano voice I have ever heard”. In the intervening years that followed, that initial assessment not only had not waivered but, if anything, been validated time and again. The basic timber of the voice has changed remarkably little – pure silver and velvet that some find to be “coolly detached”, while others relish in its soft caresses. Whichever side of the Kiri camp your sympathies may lie, you cannot deny her charismatic stage presence and her uncanny ability to connect with her audiences on an emotional as well as spiritual level. In Strauss’ famous Morgen, Ms. Te Kanawa sang the opening line softly in half-tone, distilling from the music the dreamy languor and wordless ecstasy that made time stand still in rapturous wonder. Pianist Julian Reynolds lent a sensitive hand as an equal creative partner rather than just an accompanist.

Besides Strauss, Ms. Te Kanawa also excelled in songs by Duparc and Poulenc. The French melodies lay comfortably in the middle of her range and showed her voice in the most flattering light. Inevitably, the voice of silver has acquired a patina of age; the sheer loveliness of timber, and of spirit, in the singing remains blissfully intact.

The remainder of the program showcased the impish wit and charm of this ageless diva, in an international collection of lighthearted songs by Heggie, Britten, Copland and Wolf-Ferrari, interspersed with humorous intros and reminiscenses. Someone at the U.N. ought to nominate Kiri for the post of Ambassador of Music and World Peace.  Maybe the world would be a better place for it. 

Tuesday also marked the first anniversary of the Renée and Henry Segerstrom Concert Hall, the OC’s new crown jewel for classical music. Kudos for the Segerstroms for this marvelous valhalla of music, and big kudos for the Philharmonic Society for bringing an opera legend to Southern California. Thank you Kiri, we shall miss you dearly.

Visit www.philharmonicsociety.org for information on the Philharmonic Society of Orange County's 2007-2008 season.


    October 5, 7  Angela Hewitt, piano
PROGRAM: J.S. Bach - Well-Tempered Clavier, Books I & II
 

W

hen Angela Hewitt played in the OC a year ago, it was as one of the duo pianists in Mozart’s Concerto for Two Pianos and made an amiable though fleeting impression.  This time around, however, she came with double barrels blazing – playing Books I and II of  J.S. Bach’s Well-Tempered Clavier with wonderful polish and dazzling Technicolor. 

Playing on a fantastic-sounding Fazioli 10.7-foot concert grand (longer than a Boesendorfer or a Steinway model “D”), Hewitt was able to articulate a marvelous range of timber and color and turn elegant phrases that brought these 48 Preludes and Fugues to life.  Starting from the soft-as-silk C-major Prelude (Book I), to the exhilarating virtuosity of No.15 G-major Fugue (Book I), to the gentle, pulsating lyricism of No.22 B-flat minor Prelude (Book II), Hewitt made a convincing case for Bach as the most ‘romantic’ of composers.  During her playing, there was a feeling of absolute piety and devotion to the task at hand, her arms raising high in the air as if in a prayer, her body swaying and rollicking to the maximum energy of a fugue.  Hewitt brought a sense of physicality and poetry to these works matched by few other pianists. 
 

Clearly Hewitt is on a mission, a missionary who is relentless in her zeal to spread the Gospel according to J.S. Bach.  Her forty-city world tour of the ‘Bach 48’ (why not make it forty-eight cities and bill it as ’48 in 48’?)  is a daunting proposition designed to challenge her sanity and endurance as well as ours in the audience.  This is not for the faint of heart, only the diehard musical cognoscenti need apply, and I saw quite a few of them in the audience, with a score in hand, perusing and frequently nodding their heads in approval.  For the most part I found myself rejoicing with them in the collective show of Bach mania.

Most, but not all.  The rubato in some of the contemplative, inner-looking fugues could be excessive, thwarting their forward momentum (the No.8 D-sharp minor of Book II, for example).  But in the final analysis, among today’s handful pianists who have tackled the daunting ‘Bach 48’, none is as consistently persuasive and illuminating as Angela Hewitt.  Bouquets also for Paolo Fazioli for his fabulous, 'scientifically-engineered' instrument, which many consider the finest piano in the world today.  

Visit www.philharmonicsociety.org for information on the Philharmonic Society of Orange County's 2007-2008 season.

 


 October 13  Pasadena Symphony/Jonathan Haas, timpani

PROGRAM: Silvestre Revueltas- Homage to Lorca. Hector Berlioz- 3 Suites from Romeo et Juliette. Philip Glass- Concerto Fantasy for Two Timpanists & Orchestra
 

P

asadena may be in the suburbia of Los Angeles, but it has everything a big city has to offer.  It is a small city that dares to dream big – the Rose Parade, the Huntington Library (with its under-construction 100-plus-acre Chinese Garden), Caltech, and the world-class Pasadena Symphony. 

Celebrating its 80th Anniversary and its recent merger with the Pasadena Pops, last Saturday’s season-opening concert mixed the classic with the popular, the Romantic with the Minimalist, the profane with the sublime.  The result was a smashing hit.

The unusual program opens with Homage to Lorca by the now-forgotten Mexican composer Silvestre Revueltas.  It is orchestrated for a brass band, strings, a flute, a piano, and a xylophone.  The slow, somber march for the brass band, punctuated by the xylophone and piano chords, eerily evokes the execution of the Mandarin prince from Puccin’s last opera “Turandot”.  Darkness soon gives way to light and the work ends on an ebullient, festive note.  The performance by members of the Pasadena Symphony and pianist Gloria Cheng was topnotch.

Hector Berlioz is probably the most democratic of all composers.  The Romantic period was dominated by individual geniuses as demigods worshipped by their most ardent fans.  Franz Liszt was the piano god, Nicolo Paganini the violin demon, Maria Malibran the opera’s prima donna assoluta, and so on.  In the works of Berlioz, all instruments (and voices) are treated equal and each is allowed its opportunity to shine.  There are no self-serving soloists, only a democratic ensemble of virtuoso players whose aim is to serve the drama and the poet.  For Berlioz, there was no greater poet than Shakespeare, and he poured all his resources and orchestral wizardry into the composition of Romeo et Juliette

In this concert, we heard only the three famous orchestral suites (sans the choral and soloist parts) – The Queen Mab Scherzo was predictably light and fleet, though without quite the gossamer transparency I would have liked.  The Balcony Scene was a beautiful orchestral tableau of sweet and tender love.  The Capulet’s Party Scene started with Romeo’s lonely entry (beautifully played on the oboe by Leanne Becknell) and crescendoed into a swirling, giddy dance of the most brilliant colors and sonorities.  It was as much a tribute to Berlioz’s genius as to conductor Jorge Mester’s masterful (pun intended) reading. 

I have only one word for Philip Glass’ Duo-Timpanist Concerto Fantasy – to borrow a Hollywood term – a blockbuster.  I had previously reviewed timpanist Jonathan Haas' CD on these pages, so I knew I was in for a treat.  I wasn’t disappointed.  Haas is, dare I say, the Paganini of the timpani in his ability to conjure up a whole new palette of sounds and shades heretofore undreamed of on a timpani.  I admit to be no fan of Glass’ music in general, but with playing of such a high caliber as this (and that of co-timpanist John Evans), it made me sit up and listen – seriously. 

This unusually strong show of force in the opening augured well for the Pasadena Symphony’s 2007-2008 Season. 

For future concerts and ticket information go to www.pasadenasymphony.org

 




 
October 14  Los Angeles Master Chorale

PROGRAM: Beethoven- Calm Sea and Prosperous Voyage. Brahms- A German Requiem (Ein deutsches Requiem).  Grant Gershon, conductor. Elissa Johnston, soprano, Stephen Powell, baritone
 

T

he performances of religious works in the concert hall (or even the opera house) have always been problematic.  Ambient echoes and acoustics account for much of the effect a religious work has upon its audience.  The more ‘live’ and reverberant the hall’s acoustics, the greater the sense of religiosity and spiritual connection the hearer will have with the music, regardless of the virtues of the performance itself.  In the case of Brahms’ Eine deutsches Requiem, the work sounds infinitely better in a church than in a standard concert hall.

Except the Walt Disney isn’t a standard concert hall.   

An instant classic since its opening in 2003, the Disney Hall has fabulously ‘live’ acoustics that amplifies tenfold any crack or imperfection of a performance.  On the other hand, it makes any normal music-making sound great, and any great performance sound positively divine.  The Los Angeles Master Chorale’s season-opening concert of Eine deutsches Requiem was just such a great performance.

Conductor and Master Chorale Director Grant Gershon captured perfectly the spirit of this work – the joy, the hope, the exultation of the glorious afterlife awaiting our dearly departed.  It is not a Requiem of the usual fire-and-brimstone variety, but a comforting affirmation that all is well in the afterlife, that death is not something to be dreaded.   Gershon coaxed some beautifully nuanced playing and singing from his Master Chorale and the Master Chorale Orchestra (some of the finest freelancers around).  The chorale ‘Wie lieblich sind deine Wohnungen’ (how lovely is Thy dwelling place) was supremely lyrical, accentuated by exquisite pizzicato strings and shimmering flutes.  The many choral fugues and double-fugues were dispatched with tremendous brio, and sounded absolutely ecstatic when combined with the joyous pealing of the Disney Hall’s 6134-pipe organ (played by William Beck).  Baritone Stephen Powell’s firm and incisive singing was a pleasure in “Herr lehre doch mich” and “Siehe ich sage euch ein Geheimnis”.   Soprano Elissa Johnston, whom I have admired on many previous occasions, was not on good form and showed obvious intonation problems and a widened vibrato at dynamics above mezza forte, although her soft singing in “Ihr habt nun Traurigkeit” was quite lovely.

Beethoven's Goethe-inspired choral study of sailing, Calm Sea and Prosperous Voyage, was a nice seven-minute warmup for the Brahms.  The L.A. Master Chorale gave a stirring and highly atmospheric account of this mini-masterpiece. 

Visit www.lamc.org for information on L.A. Master Chorale's 2007-2008 season.


 

   

Truman C. Wang is editor-in-chief of Classical Voice, whose articles have appeared in the San Gabriel Valley Tribune, the Pasadena Star-News, other Southern California publications, as well as the Hawaiian Chinese Daily.

 

 

[ previous | back to top ]