Classical Voice  : Notable Notes
 

Notable Notes --  January, 2005

By
Truman C. Wang
January 31, 2005


Jan 15  Pasadena Symphony/Jennifer Frautschi, violinist
PROGRAM: Liadov- symphonic poem "Kikimora", Tchaikovsky- Violin concerto, Shostakovich- Symphony No. 10 in E minor. Jorge Mester, conductor
The Pasadena Symphony hit its stride last Saturday night with an all-Russian program of Shostakovich, Tchaikovsky and...Liadov.  Liadov? He was all but forgotten today for writing fairytale music in an era of anxiety and post-war angst. His symphony poem "Kikimora" portrays a mischievous goblin with a rich orchestral palette, including a humorously lugubrious cor angelis solo in the opening.  Tchaikovsky's ever-popular violin concerto received a pleasant, warm reading from Ms. Frautschi, an accomplished chamber music artist, who opted for lyrical intimacy rather than cold brilliance.  One would have wished for more tension in the buildup to the presto finale, but overall it's a most solid, congenial performance.  Shostakovich's tenth symphony is notable for its cyclical motif and for the first appearance of the DSCH personal monogram in his music.  Conductor Jorge Mester's tempi, phrasing and dynamics were right on the mark per Shostakovich's score and there were no excesses of angst, since it is all too fashionable these days to play his scores as if our entrails were lying bloodied, on the floor. This tends to make the pieces much more hysterical than they are. His music deserves better. Maestro Mester served the composer admirably by not letting the emotional elements run amok, but instead letting the music speak for itself.  Bravo!
 
  Jan 27  L.A. Opera - Aida
CAST: Michele Crider (Aida), Franco Farina (Radames), Irina Mishura (Amneris), Lado Ataneli (Amonastro), Reinhard Hagen (Pharaoh), Arutjun Kotchinian (Ramfis), Jamie Chamberlin (Priestess), Peter Nathan Foltz (Messenger), Susan Gladstone (Solo Dancer- Head Priestess), Shell Bauman (Solo Dancer- Egyptian leader), Rocklin Thompson (Solo Dancer- Ethiopian leader).
After the exhilarating spear battle dance in Act II finale, which choreographer Peggy Hickey famously dubbed “Verdi’s Rite of Spring”, there can be no doubt that opera in L.A. boasts not just dance, a cursory affair at best in most U.S. opera houses, but real choreography. The names of three solo dancers show prominently in the program – all of whom deserve kudos for their outstanding work. L.A. Opera assembled a dream cast with Michele Crider in the eponymous role – innocent and pure in a fautlessly-intoned “Numi pieta”, and unflinchingly defiant in the dramatic Amneris-Aida duet. Irina Mishura’s Amneris was another ideal portrayal that spanned t! he emotional gamut from vengeance to pity with every vocal hues in between. What has happened to Franco Farina, an erstwhile run-of-the-mill tenor who has gone big league? The seemingly inexhaustible breath and the ravishing mezza voce soft singing (a pity he didn’t attempt it at the end of “Celeste Aida”) that were the mark of a great tenor. The balance of the huge cast were memorable for Lado Ataneli’s emotionally overpowering Amonastro and Peter Nathan Foltz’s incisive singing in a small role of the messenger. The only fly in the ointment was the lackluster conducting of Dan Ettinger, whose unidiomatic reading and tempi threatened to drown out and derail the efforts onstage. Clearly, maestro Ettinger is no singers’ conductor. The set design by Pier Luigi Pizzi features simple but powerful angular lines that effectively evoke the grandeur of ancient Egypt.  With this Aida, the Los Angeles Opera has struck gold in Egypt.
 
  Jan 29  L.A. Opera - Romeo et Juliette
CAST: Rolando Villazon (Romeo), Anna Netrebko (Juliette), Anna-Maria Panzarella (Stephano), Florian Laconi (Tybalt), Marc Barrardo (Mercutio), Simone Alberghini (Lord Capulet), Suzanna Guzman (Nurse). Frederic Chaslin, conductor
Believe it or not, there are over 200 operas based on Shakespeare's plays -- from the faithful adaptations (e.g. Verdi's Otello) to the very loose (e.g. Bellini's I Capuletti ed i Montecchi)  Gounod's take on the Bard's play is full of amiable melodies with some fine dramatic moments, notably the lovers' duet in Act One, Romeo's exile in Act Three's ensemble finale, and the extended suicide scene in Act Five (operatic conventions require that Romeo live to sing a final duet with Juliet before they both expire together.) 
And how this Romeo sang!  Tenor Rolando Villazon's virile, suave vocalism was balm to these ears chronically assaulted by brawny, tasteless tenor singing.  Villazon effortlessly sailed through the long arching lines of "leve toi soleil" with a single breath and into the hearts of the audience.  As Juliette, Anna Netrebko sang and acted beautifully -- if in a rather generic sort of way, and without the requisite trill in her Act IV "potion" aria.  A surprise find was mezzo-soprano Anna-Maria Panzarella, who gave a sparkling account of Stephano's aria.  Remember La Panzarella!  The drab, dark, skeletal set design by John Gunter supposedly portrays the stark psychological states of the star-crossed Verona lovers.  Director Ian Judge opts for 'reality opera' with a gratuitous, raunchy sex scene that drew smirks and groans rather than artful appreciation from the audience.  Conductor Frederic Chaslin wielded a sensitive baton and brought out the shimmering beauty of Gounod's score.

 
   

Truman C. Wang is editor-in-chief of Classical Voice, whose articles have appeared in the San Gabriel Valley Tribune, the Pasadena Star-News and other Southern California publications.

 

 

[ previous | back to top ]