Concert Review                                by Classical Voice
 

A concert of maximum Minimalism, works by Arvo Pärt, Meredith Monk

By
Douglas Neslund
May 11, 2010


The Los Angeles Master Chorale


Pärt:   Miserere
Monk:   WEAVE (West Coast Premiere)
Monk:   Night
Monk:   Songs of Ascension (Selections)

Grant Gershon, Music Director

April 11, 2010 at Walt Disney Concert Hall


T

wo iconic composers of the minimalist persuasion were on the menu at the Los Angeles Master Chorale’s lets-go-informal-and-wear-“something black”-instead-of-our-formalwear night. The reason for this choice of haberdashery didn’t become obvious until the end of the concert.  Arvo Pärt, the Estonian minimalist composer, has a large and favorable following perhaps because his music is accessible and doesn’t seek either to shock or dismember the audience with a million tiny nicks of a sonic buzzsaw or to bore them with mechanized non-inspiration.

His Miserere, composed in 1989 and revised in 1992, evolves from a solo tenor intonation with clarinet commentary into the full-blown choral and instrumental fury of an interpolated “Dies Irae” (Day of Wrath), which is followed by soloists – Claire Fedoruk, Soprano; Kimberly Switzer, Mezzo Soprano; Michael Lichtenauer and Shawn Kirchner, Tenors; and Scott Graff, Bass, all of whom were required to have an acute sense of pitch, and these named singers do – reverting to calm Psalm quotations. A return of the Dies Irae theme appears in sequenced fashion over Holocaust implications, followed by requisite penitential musings and a final organ postlude. Our 48-member Master Chorale performed at their usual professional best.

Meredith Monk surely has a near-fanatic fan base, including but not limited to fans flying in from foreign ports of call to attend this concert. Audience Building 101.

Her minimalism takes a different course from, say, John Adams, in that she captures all the sounds of nature and among other pursuits of border bending, deploys the human voice with glottal stops. Most singers are warned while learning vocal technique about glottal stops, as too much use of them may be damaging to the vocal mechanism, notwithstanding the German language’s generous use of them without harm done. On this occasion, Mezzo Soprano Katie Geissinger started Monk’s “Weave” with a series of notes initiated by “strokes of the glottis. This created an effect not normally heard when humans sing, and is exactly the sort of experimental sounds of nature that Ms. Monk seeks to explore. Unfortunately, as the Monk portion of the concert unwound, Ms. Geissinger’s voice grew ever more husky, lacking earlier focus, in spite of her obvious music talents. Sometimes experimentation takes a toll. Ms. Geissinger travels with Ms. Monk and her company of singers and instrumentalists, thus longer-term exposure to glottal stops amount to a moveable hazard.

But glottal stops were only one of a myriad of sounds evoked through “Weave”, a work co-commissioned by the Los Angeles Master Chorale and Grand Center Inc., with the Ur-premier performance taking place with the St. Louis Symphony. Such aggregation of sounds takes place within an unstated framework of “naturalism,” something akin to Native American ethos. But it is so much more than the caricature banging on drums and chanting for rain. Her themes are about life, philosophy, and perhaps unfortunately, politics. It is this kinship of art and politics appearing now and again in Los Angeles Master Chorale concerts that is disconcerting (yes, a pun). But c.f. Audience Building 101. When political balance is restored via a rousing, traditional rah-rah of “When Johnny Comes Marching Home” replete with Boy Scouts carrying American flags and the music of Stephen Foster, Charles Ives, Aaron Copland and George Gershwin, then political neutrality will be restored … (or not).

Nevertheless, Ms. Monk was received by the audience with eager shouts and applause, and her own performances of “Night” and “Songs of Ascension” following intermission revealed a pig-tailed performer able to capture and charge the Walt Disney Concert Hall atmosphere, including a subtle light show and Buddhist reference, sprawling alone onstage with her iconic shruti box between her legs, to weave the spirit of otherworldliness that to a mostly rat-race audience, is beguiling at least, and inspiring at best. Her voice is said to span three octaves. But most singers can span three octaves – the highest and lowest utterances are not useable in performance of traditional music, but Ms. Monk can and does, because accepted traditional vocal quality are irrelevant in her world.

Ms. Monk’s traveling troupe of musicians included the importance of baritone Theo Bleckmann in both “Weave” and “Songs of Ascension”, and in the latter, Tenors Tom Bogdan and Matthew Brown, Sopranos Emily Lin and Allison Sniffin, (who collaborated on the orchestrations), Mezzo Sopranos Katie Geissinger and Andriana Manfredi, Tenors Mr. Bogdan and Matthew Brown and LAMC member Kimberly Switzer, with Baritone Melvir Ausente. Journeyman instrumentalist Bohdan Hilash played bass clarinet, and local pros Ralph Morrison and Nina Evtuhov, were violinists, Shawn Mann, violist, and Maurice Grants, ‘cellist. All instrumentalists were well prepared, whether members of the composer’s troupe or local pros.

In the final movement of “Songs of Ascension”, Ms. Monk’s soloists followed her slow-motion act of assuming a prone face-up repose onstage. When Maestro Grant Gershon joined them, the audience tittered loudly, apparently remembering the far more touching and appropriate involvement of conductor with score in Tan Dun’s “Water Passion” of several seasons ago.

All of which was followed by an encore set in circle formation for cheering fans, while others scurried their way back to real life.

 


For tickets to other Los Angeles Master Chorale concerts, call (213) 972-7211 or visit www.lamc.org

 

   

Douglas Neslund is Classical Voice correspondent and a noted voice/choral teacher in Los Angeles. 

 

 

 

[ previous | back to top ]