Opera Review                                by Classical Voice
 

The Magic Flute, As Perfect As It Gets

By
Truman C. Wang
Friday, April 12, 2002


ZAUBERFLÖTE, K.620

Opera in Two Acts by
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Sung in German with English titles

Tamino……………Bruce Sledge
Pamina……………Andrea Rost
Papageno…………Rodney Gilfry
Konegin…………..Sumi Jo
Sarastro…………..Reinhard Hagen
Monostatos……...Greg Fedderly
Speaker…………...James Creswell
First Lady………...Robin Follman
Second Lady……..Cynthia Jansen
Third Lady………..Suzanna Guzman
Papagena…………Shana Blake Hill
First Spirit………...Lauren Libaw
Second Spirit……..Daniel Reardon
Third Spirit……….Aidan Schultz-Meyer

Lawrence Foster, conductor
Sir. Peter J. Hall, production designer
Stanley M. Garner, stage director
Gerald Scarfe, set and costume designer
Michael Gottlieb, lighting designer

Performance of Friday, April 12, 2002 at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion


All photos by KEN HOWARD, courtesy of Los Angeles Opera

LOS ANGELES, CALIF -- Is there a more magical, more enchanting, or more profoundly human work for the lyric stage than Mozart’s The Magic Flute?   I do not think so, especially where the marriage of the producer’s conception and the composer’s intentions was such a happy one as the Los Angeles Opera’s revival of Sir Peter Hall’s 1993 production.

Mozart began writing the score of The Magic Flute in Vienna in June 1791, and had already completed the main body of the work by the end of September before he was summoned to Prague to supervise the staging of his final, coronation opera La Clemenza di Tito.  During the time while Mozart was away in Prague, his librettist/impresario Emanuel Schikaneder busied himself with devising novel stage effects and costumes that would guarantee the show a big hit with the working-class tavern-drinking crowd.  It is well known that Mozart incorporated the Freemasonic symbolism of Three’s in the opera’s music and plot (three flats in the key of E-flat that begins and ends the opera, three Spirits, three Ladies, thrice-repeated chords, etc.)   These allegorical symbols soon took on an almost metaphysical significance for later audiences and interpreters of the work (who mistook slow tempi for profundity).   Therefore, for the modern producer and stage director of The Magic Flute, the thorny question is, “how to balance the mythical with the human elements?”

The answer, according to the Los Angeles Opera’s new production team, is simple:  Set the opera in a vaguely Egyptian locale (i.e., Pyramids and half-man, half-Sphinx beings) and populate it with exotic creatures (e.g., a half-crocodile, half-penguin hybrid) and colorful costumes (e.g., Papageno’s feather-covered leotard, Pamina’s gleaming art-deco gown, and Tamino’s red-lined Oriental suit.)   This never-never land provides an exotic backdrop for human interactions, and the characters thereby take on a larger-than-life, allegorical significance.


The action takes place in Ancient Egypt (circa 4,000 B.C.).  Sarastro, high priest of Isis, has abducted Pamina, daughter of the malevolent Queen of the Night, in order to impart wisdom to her.  Saved from a huge serpent from the Queen’s three attendant ladies, the Japanese Prince Tamino sets out to rescue Pamina.  He is accompanied by Papageno, the happy-go-lucky bird catcher.  However, in trying to effect Pamina’s release he himself becomes taken up with the high ideals of Sarastro and his followers.  He becomes initiated into the Order and, finally, is married to Pamina, who has by now absorbed all the wisdom to which she has been exposed.

As Tamino, tenor Bruce Sledge, a third-year Los Angeles Opera resident artist, had plenty of weight but not a lot of natural lyricism, nor did he move well on stage.  It was a very acceptable performance but not a particularly appealing one, and in the opening ‘Portrait’ aria there were two or three moments that did not seem to me perfectly tuned.  In the Act Two encounter scene with Pamina, who let out a sweet, poignant cry “Tamino mein!  O welch ein Glück!”, Mr. Sledge repeated the same phrase clumsily, with neither a sign of ardor nor grace – One felt as if being doused over the head with a bucket of cold water.

The Korean-born, Italian-trained soprano Sumi Jo’s Queen of Night was on the light side, without great weight in the upper register but very fluent and spirited in the coloratura and as near to perfect in her pitching of it as one could reasonably expect.  And there was a real glow and presence to the tone, in the middle register particularly, that makes her first aria “O zittre nicht” very telling.  Her second aria “Der Hölle Rache” was taken at a slower pace than usual, but with spectacular results that matched her equally spectacular shimmering black peacock-feathered overdress.

German bass Reinhard Hagen delivered a really splendid Sarastro, deep, duly authoritative, and warm in tone, with a quiet nobility in "In diesen heil’gen Hallen"; and James Creswell's Speaker had a pleasing weight and fluency.   The Three Ladies formed a lively, perky trio, and the Three Spirits were feathery-toned and sounding appropriately angelic (although I would have preferred a fuller sound.)  Greg Fedderly’s green dwarf of a Monostatos looked like a caricature but, thankfully, did not sing like one.  Shana Blake Hill was a delightfully girlish Papagena. 

The popular American baritone Rodney Gilfry was clearly the darling of the audience, judging from the amount of laughs he received for his crackling delivery of dialogs and for his unerring comic timing.  Make no mistake, though, behind the guise of a lovable buffoon was a serious musician.  Mr. Gilfry sang the two strophic songs of Papageno with mellifluous lines and unfailing musicality. 

Hungarian soprano Andrea Rost, making her Los Angeles Opera debut, was as fine a Pamina as one could wish for.  Her petite frame and wide-eyed innocent look conceal a voice of radiant beauty that, when required, is capable of unleashing great power with utter security.   A natural actress who moves as elegantly as she sings, Ms. Rost left an indelible impression even in her first scene.  As the evening progressed, the charm and girlish vivacity gradually blossomed into maturity and passion in the cry of “Die Wahrheit!” and in the aforementioned “Tamino mein!”.  In her scene with the Three Spirits, Pamina begged them to take her to her beloved Tamino (“Führt mich hin, ich möcht ihn sehn / take me there. I want to see him”) with a cloying sweetness that would melt the hardest heart.  In the ensuing ensemble, the voice rose higher and higher in a show of great emotional outpouring and ended with a touchingly executed downward scale in “die Götter selbsten schützen sie / the gods themselves protect them”.  Ms. Rost achieved lyrical apotheosis with her gorgeously sung “Ach, ich fül’s”, taken at an unhurried pace, thus allowing the full emotional weight to register.  Her perfectly poised soft B-flats, her honeyed legato on the slow ascending scales, all created such magical effects that one would not soon forget.  Ms Rost is one of the great Mozartians of our time, perhaps of all time.

The inexplicably slow, portentous introduction of the overture belied the vital, rhythmically buoyant reading that was soon to follow.  Conductor Lawrence Foster, on loan from Barcelona, took the Romantic view of the score – broad tempos with no appoggiaturas (nor cadenza for the Three Ladies, which Mozart cut before the premiere).  The final phrases of “Ach, ich fuhl's”, as the wind instruments slowly fell away and left Pamina alone and desolate, were very moving indeed.  The chorus sang with stirring high spirits in the two act finales.



Truman C. Wang is editor of Classical Voice.

 

 

 

 

[ previous | back to top ]