Concert Review                          by Classical Voice
 

Violinist Gives an Intimate and Immaculate Reading of Sibelius

By
Truman C. Wang
Saturday, November 16, 2002


LOS ANGELES, CALIF – The Nov. 16 concert by the Los Angeles Philharmonic was memorable for the superb orchestral playing as well as for the presence of a great violinist.   The three Nordic pieces on the program found their ideal interpreter in the L.A. Phil’s  Finnish-born conductor/artistic director Esa-Pekka Salonen. 

Edvard Grieg’s Peer Gynt Suite had all the requisite pastoral charm and vivacity that the score demands and more.  Aase’s Death, marked ‘andante doloroso’, was unforgettable for its quietly shimmering sonorities, like a translucent dark veil on a bereaved lover.

The dark force again re-asserted itself in the Sibelius Violin Concerto, here given a rapturously serene and intimate account by Midori and the Philharmonic musicians, who at times played like chamber musicians.  It is a tribute to Midori’s mastery that in concert her playing has all the precision one would expect in the studio – exceptionally clean and precise, not least above the stave.  The main lyrical themes of the first two movements were taken at leisurely tempos and built up gradually to rapt intensity, and the coda of the first movement was among the most thrilling I have ever heard.  The finale, adhering to Sibelius’ exact marking “allegro ma non tanto”, was again remarkable for the clean precision of her playing, with detail sharply drawn even in the most thorny bravura passages.

Carl Nielsen’s Fifth Symphony is a dark but poetic work that calls for a rich and velvet body of strings like an atmospheric sea painting.  Here it received a first-rate reading by the Philharmonic.  The mournful solo clarinet (superbly played by Michelle Zukovsky) in the opening set the ominous tone for the snare drum insurgence that was too come.  The brief romantic interlude had the soft radiance of the Northern Light in the otherwise desolate seascape.

The concert will repeat at 2:00pm, Sunday, Nov.17.


Truman C. Wang is editor of Classical Voice.

 

[ previous | back to top ]